The AMA v. Dobbs. Part 2. – The Health Care Blog

The AMA v. Dobbs. Part 1. – The Health Care Blog


Really should anybody current know of any explanation that this couple must not be joined in holy matrimony, converse now or endlessly maintain your peace.”     Book of Popular Prayer, Church of England, 1549

Last evening Trump rose from the ashes and declared it was time to “Make America Good and Wonderful Again” (MAGAGA).

This past week, 5 days just after the Midterm elections, AMA President, Jack Resnick, Jr., MD, lifted his voice from the podium at the AMA Interim Meeting in Hawaii with the AMA’s very own variation of a simply call to motion:

But make no mistake, when politicians insert by themselves in our test rooms to interfere with the affected person-medical doctor marriage, when they politicize deeply personal health choices, or criminalize evidence-based mostly care, we will not again down…I never imagined colleagues would uncover on their own tracking down hospital lawyers ahead of executing urgent abortions, when minutes rely … asking if a 30% probability of maternal dying, or impending renal failure, meet up with the conditions for the point outs exemptions … or irrespective of whether they ought to wait around a when for a longer time, until eventually their pregnant patient gets even sicker…Enough is sufficient. We can not allow for physicians or our sufferers to come to be pawns in these lies.”

Above a 12 months in the past, they had signaled consciousness that attacks on Roe v. Wade might basically obstacle client autonomy and the sanctity of the affected person-doctor partnership. On September 21, 2021, the AMA with 25 other professional medical corporations submitted an amicus temporary in opposition to the restrictive Mississippi abortion law, Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Group.  And on  Oct 12, 2021, 19 professional medical societies, with the AMA in the direct, filed  an amicus transient in U.S. v. Texas, the abortion vigilante regulation signed by Gov. Greg Abbott.

Above the past 12 months, the AMA had ample warning that the circumstance was spinning out of control. On June 27, 2022, I wrote: “My issue today, regardless of the strong messaging from Chicago, is that the AMA and its membership have not totally absorbed that this is a ‘mission-critical’ second in the organization’s history… The strong words, devoid of steps to again them up will permanently seal the AMA’s destiny, and obstacle Medicine’s position as a ‘profession.’”

I was reacting to the AMA’s assertion three days previously, on release of the Dobbs selection, which labeled the decision “an egregious allowance of governing administration intrusion into the medical assessment room, a immediate attack on the practice of medicine and the affected person-physician relationship…the AMA condemns the large court’s interpretation in this situation. We will constantly have physicians’ backs and defend the follow of medication, we will combat to protect the client-physician romantic relationship.”

At the time, I suggested that the AMA mobilize and orchestrate their Federation state and specialty societies to go after acts of “physician ‘civil disobedience’ in which appropriate to guard the wellness and properly currently being of all gals, regardless of age, race, sexual identity, religion, or economic standing.”

This warning arrived six months after I highlighted Charles Dickens phrases in a “Tale of Two Cities” – “It was the finest of times, it was the worst of moments, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, …” – as a way to dramatize that we also are a “tale of two cities”  as this map of the United States, colour coded for regressive laws and techniques to disenfranchise women and young children, folks of coloration, the poor and the vulnerable, properly illustrates.

On November 8, 2022, the AMA internet site posted a part titled “Advocacy in action: Defending reproductive health.” But a constructive critic would be justified in suggesting that the prepare is tall on “advocacy”, but limited on “action.”

What does “action” glimpse like? In Part 2 of this piece, I’ll present examples from Michigan, Kansas, Kentucky, and Washington.


Mike Magee MD is a Clinical Historian and creator of “CODE BLUE: Inside the Professional medical Industrial Intricate.”

Leave a Reply